Scrapbook Photo 04/15/24 - 66 New Stories - REAL Environmental & Conservation Leadership In PA:
EPA Will Develop Its Own Chesapeake Bay Nutrient, Sediment Reduction Goals For PA

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency notified Pennsylvania Friday it will be developing Pennsylvania-specific goals for reducing nutrients and sediment in the Pennsylvania portion of the Chesapeake Bay Watershed to help the Commonwealth get back on track to meeting its 2025 TMDL cleanup commitments.

The notice was part of a new progress report EPA issued reporting on how states are doing in meeting their Chesapeake Bay Watershed cleanup milestones.  For Pennsylvania, there were no surprises-- it was bad news.

Half of Pennsylvania is within the Chesapeake Bay Watershed drainage area.

Pennsylvania did not meet its 2015 goal for nitrogen and sediment pollution reduction (although it did for phosphorus) and will not meet its 2017 goals for nitrogen and phosphorus, but will meet its goal for sediment.

EPA already has Pennsylvania at so-called backstop levels for agricultural and urban/suburban stormwater sectors.  This means they have substantial concerns with Pennsylvania’s strategy to implement measures to achieve the goals and it may take federal action to get the state back on track.

In its evaluation Friday, EPA said Pennsylvania’s latest plan for getting its Chesapeake Bay cleanup program back on track does not include any milestones to increase the number of agricultural conservation practices on the ground and no additional requests for more resources to make that happen.

EPA specifically offered Pennsylvania contractor assistance to build the capacity for developing Manure Management Plans and Agricultural Erosion and Sedimentation Plans in priority watersheds in support of the state’s efforts.

EPA said it will also be conducting its own assessments (meaning inspections) of animal feeding operations to determine whether the farms are complying with state Manure and Erosion and Sedimentation Plan requirements.

EPA said it may also offer assistance to local initiatives designed to assist Pennsylvania in achieving its nutrient and sediment reduction goals.

EPA recommended, Pennsylvania and the other states in the Susquehanna River Watershed, develop a strategy to reduce nutrient and sediment loads now coming through the Conowingo Dam as a result of its reservoir filling up and losing its trapping capacity.

Among the specific obligations missed or to be completed by Pennsylvania were--

-- Did not complete the development and implementation of its farm conservation tracking and reporting system in 2015;

-- Did not increase implementation of priority practices to improve water quality such as grass buffers and nutrient management;

-- EPA expects Pennsylvania to develop a list of geographic areas with the greatest nutrient pollutant load reduction potential in order to target funding to those areas;

-- Did not increase implementation of stormwater management best management practices in urban areas to address the load reductions currently committed to;

-- EPA expects Pennsylvania to include a milestone to develop a trading and offset policy for post construction stormwater;

-- DEP did not develop a stormwater offset [credit trading] program and is recommending to stop pursuing a stormwater offset program.  Pennsylvania needs to explain how stormwater trading and offsets will be addressed.

The detailed assessment of Pennsylvania’s progress in meeting its own Chesapeake Bay Watershed cleanup commitments is available online.


In reaction to EPA’s milestones report Friday, Harry Campbell, PA Director of the Chesapeake Bay Foundation, said, While Pennsylvania is on track to meet its 2017 target for reducing the amount of sediment damaging our waterways, it has a long way to go if it is to reduce nitrogen and phosphorus pollution, mainly from agriculture.

“Pennsylvania’s rebooted strategy can be a catalyst for the Clean Water Blueprint to reduce pollution damaging our rivers and streams, but without the necessary funding it will not succeed. Sadly, it is still unclear when or if those vital resources will be made available.

“It is time for Pennsylvania to make cleaning up our rivers and streams a priority. Our citizens have a right to clean water and as we approach the clean-up mid-point of 2017, it is unacceptable that the Commonwealth continues to languish in meeting its goals.

“Pennsylvania must take decisive action now or face consequences of EPA action.”

For more on Chesapeake Bay-related issues in Pennsylvania, visit the CBF-PA webpage.  Click Here to sign up for Pennsylvania updates (bottom of left column).  Click Here for a copy of CBF-PA’s most recent newsletter.


AP: EPA, States Behind In Tackling Chesapeake Pollution Problems

Nitrogen Pollution Reductions Lagging, EPA Warns Bay States

Chesapeake Bay Foundation Addresses Issues With Susquehanna River

Agencies Find Common Concern In Susquehanna River

Crable: Growing Greener Grant Helps Farmers In Pequea Watershed

Crable: Festival Will Celebrate, Not Vilify, Swarms On Susquehanna Mayflies

Crable: Lights Out On Columbia Bridge In Advance Of Mayfly Hordes

Susquehanna Mayfly Hatch Imminent, Bridge Lights Shut Off

New Attempt To Move Shad Past Conowingo, Other Dams Long Term Project

June 21 Watershed Event At Wyndridge Farms In York County

Record Setting Schuylkill Sojourn Highlights River’s Wild Beauty

Get Wild About Watersheds, Urban Greening, West Philly Nature

Delaware RiverKeeper June 10 RiverWatch Video Report

Latest From The Chesapeake Bay Journal

Click Here to subscribe to the Chesapeake Bay Journal

Related Stories:

Chesapeake Bay Journal: Despite Progress, States To Fall Short Of Bay Cleanup Targets

EPA Administrator Calls PA’s Lagging Chesapeake Bay Cleanup Discouraging

DEP, Conservation Districts Work On Farm Inspections In Chesapeake Bay Watershed

DEP Tells House Committees Chesapeake Bay Program Faces Inadequate Resources, Data

Dams On Susquehanna Are Undoing Progress In Reducing Pollution To Chesapeake Bay

Agencies Unveil New Chesapeake Bay Cleanup Strategy

DCNR Leading Statewide Forest Buffer Effort To Improve Water Quality

PA Coalition Emerges To Support Farmers In Effort To Clean Up Chesapeake Bay

CBF-PA: Lack Of Funding For Farmers Defeats Effort To Meet Clean Water Commitment

CBF Op-Ed: Farm Bureau Can Choose To Be A Sore Loser Or Part Of The Solution

Rock Lititz Project Reduces Sediment, Nutrient Runoff Without Taxpayer Money


    Go To Next Article

Return to This PA Environment Digest's Main Page