Scrapbook Photo 09/24/23 - 92 New Stories - REAL Environmental & Conservation Leadership In PA:
House Committee To Hold Hearing On Alternative Natural Gas, Electric Ratemaking Nov. 20

The House Consumer Affairs Committee is scheduled to hold a hearing November 20 on House Bill 1782 (Delozier-R-Cumberland) providing for alternative ratemaking for natural gas and electric distribution companies (sponsor summary).

According to an analysis of the bill distributed to the Committee by the PA Environmental Council, the bill will allow for the voluntary use of alternative ratemaking mechanisms by natural gas and electric utilities, including decoupling; performance-based rates; formula rates; multiyear rate plans; cost-recovery mechanisms; rates to support and fully recover the allocated costs to deploy infrastructure and distributed energy resources; or rates based on a combination of these approaches.”

The Council continued, saying, “The ways in which energy, particularly electricity, is produced and used continue to evolve, and thus, it is sensible to allow the mechanisms for setting rates to also evolve. We appreciate that the bill’s language is not prescriptive, allowing each utility the freedom to adopt new ratemaking mechanisms that best meet the needs of its territory, pending the Public Utilities Commission’s (PUC) ultimate approval.

“We believe this aspect of the legislation is important because utilities differ in many ways, including the age and condition of infrastructure, the populations they serve, and the amount and types of distributed generation in their service territory, and thus a one-size-fits-all ratemaking structure across all utilities is not appropriate.

“We are particularly interested in the potential to use alternative ratemaking to reduce or eliminate the so-called “throughput incentive,” which ties utility compensation to the amount of energy used, thus putting the utility business case at odds with energy efficiency and distributed generation efforts.

“Performance-based ratemaking, in comparison, ties utility compensation to its financial and operational outcomes, rather than the amount of natural gas or electricity used, thus allowing the utility to develop an innovative business case that serves the needs of ratepayers, helps to achieve environmental outcomes, and allows for the expansion of emerging technologies.

“Perhaps most importantly, the legislation allows for alternative ratemaking, but does not mandate it, allowing each utility, with PUC approval, to set the ratemaking mechanism(s) that best meet the needs of its customers.”

The hearing will be held in Room B-31 Main Capitol starting at 10:30.  House Committee meetings are typically webcast through the Republican Caucus website.

Rep. Robert Godshall (R-Montgomery) serves as Majority Chair of the Committee and can be contacted by sending email to: Rep. Thomas Caltagirone (D-Berks) serves as Minority Chair and can be contacted by sending email to:


PEC Blog: Getting To Zero: ZECs And The Future Of Nuclear Energy

Op-Ed: Lawmakers Should Do All They Can To Save Three Mile Island

FERC Chair Details Interim Plan To Save Coal, Nuclear Plants

FERC Interim Plan Could Aid Nuke, Coal Plants For Years

Maykuth: PJM Grid Operator Moves To Prop Up Nuclear, Coal Generators

PJM Defends Plan To Help Coal, Nuclear Power Plants In Price Proposal

Grid Watchdog Finds Natural Gas Is Reliable, Could Undermine DOE Coal Plan

[Posted: Nov. 17, 2017]


Go To Preceding Article     Go To Next Article

Return to This PA Environment Digest's Main Page