On February 1, Attorney General Josh Shapiro filed 161 criminal charges against the Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority for failing to notify residents when the agency replaced lead water lines creating health risks for affected households.

The attorney general also charged the Authority with failing to sample water lines following the replacements within the time frame required under state law.

Attorney General Shapiro charged the Water & Sewer Authority with multiple violations of the Pennsylvania Safe Drinking Water Act.

The charges are third-degree misdemeanors, and the 161 counts correspond to 161 households in Pittsburgh neighborhoods where the Authority failed to notify residents of its water line replacements and failed to conduct sampling.

“Pennsylvanians have a constitutional right to clean air and pure water – I’m here to defend that,” Attorney General Shapiro said, at a news conference at a recreation center in Pittsburgh’s Lawrenceville neighborhood – an area impacted by the Authority’s violations. “The Water & Sewer Authority knew it was required to notify residents of its plans to replace service lines, and it knew it was required to sample the lines for lead content – yet it failed to do so. That makes PWSA criminally liable under the Safe Drinking Water Act.”

The Tribune Review quoted Authority Executive Director Robert A. Weimar as saying the Authority was “deeply disappointed” the Attorney General chose to pursue criminal charges, adding, “We will defend these changes.”

Weimar said the alleged violations are related to previously addressed actions that PWSA settled with the state Department of Environmental Protection in November 2017.

“We self-reported the issues to DEP, agreed to a civil penalty of $2.4 million and have since established one of the most comprehensive lead service line replacement programs in the nation,” Weimar said. “We have cooperated with DEP and addressed the issues covered by the civil settlement. Additional fines related to these previous missteps would only divert ratepayer dollars that would otherwise be used for critical water quality improvement projects and programs.”

House Speaker Mike Turzai (R-Allegheny) issued this statement in response to the action taken by the Attorney General--

“Attorney General Shapiro conducted a thorough investigation into the deficiencies at the PWSA and we applaud him for ensuring that there is accountability for those deficiencies.  It was the same concern for the public that lead us to enact legislation placing the PWSA under the oversight of the Public Utility Commission in 2017.

“PUC oversight is crucial to correcting the authority’s long-standing difficulties. The PUC has the power to demand sound financial practices, systemic upgrades to infrastructure and reliable service delivery to customers. That’s why it is imperative for us to make lasting change within the agency.”

Background

The problems involving elevated lead levels in Pittsburgh’s drinking water – and the Authority’s handling of the problems – are well-known in Pittsburgh.

The water lines installed years ago to deliver water to Pittsburghers were constructed of lead pipe. While lead pipes last for a long time, they can also leach dangerous amounts of lead into drinking water.

Children are especially sensitive to lead, which can have adverse health impacts on developing brains and lead to nervous system damage, learning disabilities and impaired hearing.

It’s also not safe for adults – potentially leading to kidney damage, high blood pressure, and reproductive issues.

Under Pennsylvania law, if the lead level in a water system exceeds 0.015 mg/L, the water system’s operator is required to take three action steps to address the high concentration--

-- Replace 7 percent of its water lines, until there are 2 consecutive monitoring periods which are at or below the action level.

-- Notify residents using the system at least 45 days prior to doing the line replacements.  Replacing the service lines can cause temporary, and potentially significant, increases in lead levels in residents’ drinking water. The notice requirement is to provide residents with information on how to minimize their exposure to lead, including how to flush your faucet, bathtub and shower to get rid of any potential lead, and a recommendation not to consume any tap water during the procedure, and more.

-- Collect samples from the replaced lines to analyze lead content within 72 hours of the new pipes being installed.

In 2016, PWSA conducted lead level tests of its system on two separate occasions, and the results each time showed lead levels in excess of the level allowed under state law.

The Department of Environmental Protection advised PWSA it must begin replacing 7 percent of their service lines to lower the lead levels in drinking water.

PWSA estimated that it needed to replace 1,341 lead lines by June 30, 2017 to meet the 7 percent requirement. However on June 30, PWSA reported that it had only replaced 415 service lines.

PWSA also admitted its failure to provide many residents with advance notice of the lines’ replacement. And, PWSA acknowledged it had not collected water samples from those same residences with new pipes within 72 hours of installation.

DEP fined PWSA $2.4 million and entered into a civil consent order and agreement in November 2017.

DEP also referred the matter for criminal investigation to the Office of Attorney General, and the referral was narrowly tailored to review PWSA’s failure to notify residents and its failure to sample water after replacement lines were installed.

The Attorney General’s office began a criminal investigation, leading to today’s charges against the Authority for 161 counts of violating the state Safe Drinking Water Act.

The maximum penalty for each count is 1 year in prison and a fine of not less than $1,250 nor more than $12,500.

Attorney General Shapiro said the charges were being filed against the Authority alone because his agents found no evidence of any one single person intending harm to any users of the system.

Attorney General Shapiro said he has arranged that whatever fines which PWSA is ultimately required to pay, the monies will be targeted by DEP to programs in Pittsburgh to protect and enhance the public health.

“This money isn’t going to a fund in Harrisburg – it’s coming back here to neighborhoods like Lawrenceville that were affected by these violations,” Shapiro said. “I hope that, with these charges, we can shine a light on these violations and force the necessary reforms to take shape to keep Pittsburgh’s drinking water safe.”

For more information on what Authority customers can do to reduce their lead exposure risk, visit the Authority’s Community Lead Response webpage.

Visit DEP’s Pittsburgh Water Authority webpage for more information on DEP’s actions on the lead service line issue in Pittsburgh.

For more information on health threats from lead in drinking water, visit DEP’s Lead In Drinking Water webpage.

More Resources

The Joint State Government Commission and a special Senate Lead Exposure Task Force will be making recommendations on reducing exposure to lead as early as April as a result of Senate Resolution 33, sponsored by Sen. John Yudichak (D-Luzerne), Minority Chair of the Senate Environmental Resources and Energy Committee.

For information on health threats from lead from other sources, visit the Department of Health’s Lead Poisoning webpage.

NewsClips:

Pittsburgh Water Authority Faces 161 Criminal Charges For Lead Water Line Violations

State AG Files Charges Against Pittsburgh Water Authority Over Lead Line Notifications

AP- Pittsburgh Water Authority Charged Criminally Over Lead Service Lines

AG Files 161 Criminal Charges Against Pittsburgh Water Authority Over Lead Levels In Water

Pittsburgh Water Authority Gearing Up To Accelerate Lead Service Line Replacements

10 Older Schools In Lancaster County Find Lead In Drinking Water

All Lancaster County Schools To Test For Lead

Crable: Ephrata Schools Send Letter To Parents Over Lead Contamination In 4 Schools

Editorial: School Ought To Be Required To Test Water For Lead, Disclose Results To Parents

NJ Landfill Agrees To Accept PFAS-Contaminated Soil From PA Military Base

NJ Landfill Backs Out Of Plan To Accept PFAS Contaminated Soil From PA

Navy Searching For New Landfill To Take PFAS Contaminated Soil From Willow Grove Base

Bagenstose: Navy Moving Ahead With PFAS Testing At Fmr Willow Grove Station

Bagenstose: Report: EPA Won’t Regulate PFAS In Drinking Water

Hurdle/Phillips: Report Says EPA Refuses To Regulate 2 PFAS Chemicals

EPA Won’t Set Legal Limit For PFAS In Drinking Water Report Says

Allentown-Lehigh Valley Water Authority Dispute Over Water/Sewer System Sale Piles Up Legal Fees

Gov. Wolf Announces $121 Million In Funding For Water Infrastructure Projects in 20 Counties, $1.1 Million For Nonpoint Projects

Related Stories:

Pittsburgh Water Authority’s Latest Drinking Water Samples Show Lead Levels Above EPA Standard

Pittsburgh Water Authority To Replace 3,400 Lead Service Lines Using PennVEST Funding In 2019

Pittsburgh Water Authority Replaced 2,048 Lead Water Service Lines In 2018, Surpassing DEP Goal

Allegheny Institute: Review Of Pittsburgh Water Authority’s 5-Year Infrastructure Plan: The Price That Has To Be Paid For Years Of Neglect

[Posted: Feb. 1, 2019]

2/4/2019