Costly Taxpayer Funded Chesapeake Bay Nutrient Reduction Procurement Bill To Be Considered June 10 In Senate Appropriations
Photo

On June 10, the Senate Appropriations Committee is scheduled to consider the costly Senate Bill 575 (Yaw-R-Lycoming) would establish a taxpayer funded procurement program for nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment reductions needed to comply with the Chesapeake Bay Watershed pollution reduction goals.

The bill was introduced May 31 and reported out of the Senate Environmental Resources and Energy Committee on June 4.

As written, the bill would guarantee only large companies with access to lots of resources could take part in the complicated bidding process established in the bill.  These companies typically promote higher cost bricks and mortar treatment solutions to deliver thousands of pounds of pollution reduction.

No small farmer, who could install much cheaper Best Management Practices in terms of cost per pound of pollution reduced through the installation of proven green infrastructure, would bother to participate in bidding with all that upfront expense and paperwork.

If the only people who can bid in these complicated process are companies with the more expensive options, this process will guarantee it presents agencies with the choice of only picking more expensive options.

Last September, Matt Johnston of the University of Maryland Chesapeake Bay Program and Dr. Emily Trentacoste of the U.S. Geological Survey presented the PA Chesapeake Bay Watershed Planning Steering Committee with the list of the top 11 most cost effective practices to reduce nitrogen going to the Chesapeake Bay based on all this experience and data in the Chesapeake Bay Program (page 73 of his presentation).

The practices include alternative crops on farmland at $1/pound of nitrogen reduced to exclusion fencing with grass buffers at $6/pound.

In between are-- less expensive to more-- were water quality conservation plans, grass buffers on row crops, barnyard runoff control, water control structures, wetland restoration, forest buffers on row crops ($2/pound), narrow buffers on row crops, narrow forest buffers on row crops and nutrient management on the land.

None of the top 11 most cost effective practices included bricks and mortar treatment solutions.

An existing, competitive Nutrient Credit Auction Program run by the PA Infrastructure Investment Authority resulted in nitrogen credit sales of $2.25 per pound last September.  The trouble is, the more expensive pollution reduction technology cannot compete in this program because their costs are too high.

The meeting will be held in the Rules Room and announced Off the Floor at one of the Senate session breaks.

Sen. Pat Browne (R-Lehigh) serves as Majority Chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee and can be contacted at 717-787-1349 or send email to: pbrowne@pasen.gov.  Sen. Vincent Hughes (D-Philadelphia) serves as Minority Chair and can be contacted at 717-787-7112 or send email to: vincent.hughes@pasenate.com.

(Photo: Sen. Browne, Majority Chair.)

Take Action!

CBF-PA: Pennsylvania's Rivers And Streams Need Your Help!  Urge Legislators To Make Critical Investments In Clean Water Now!

State Budget Decisions Will Be Made Soon: New Funding Needed To Restore The Environment, Prevent Flooding, With No Backsliding

PA Parks & Forests Foundation Urges MORE Investment, No Backsliding On Parks & Forests Project Funding

NewsClips:

Op-Ed: PA Clean Water Plan For Chesapeake Bay Needs Your Voice

Chesapeake Bay Program: Planning For A Changing Climate

Lehman Twp Exploring New Stormwater Fee Option In Luzerne

No Penalty Deadline Coming Up For Residential Stormwater Fee Payments In Luzerne

Stormwater Fees Announced In Greencastle

Related Stories:

Costly Taxpayer Funded Chesapeake Bay Nutrient Reduction Procurement Bill To Be Considered June 10 In Senate Appropriations

Senate Environmental Committee Reports Out Bills Making Fundamental Changes To The Definition Of Water Pollution, Setting Up Costly Chesapeake Bay Cleanup Program

Restore PA Infrastructure Initiative Introduced With Enough Co-Sponsors To Nearly Pass House, Senate; Republicans Say Fall At The Earliest

Republican Senators Introduce Restore PA-Lite Proposal Funded By More Drilling On State Forest Land

Senate Agriculture Committee Reports Out Farm Conservation, Noxious Weed, Other Bills

House Agriculture Committee Reports Out Farm Conservation Bills

Bay Journal: 40 Percent Of All Pennsylvania Rivers, Streams Violate Water Quality Standards

DEP Our Common Wealth Blog: How Restoring The Health Of PA's Waters Helps The Hellbender And The Chesapeake Bay!

Senate, House Resolutions Designate June 2-8 Chesapeake Bay Awareness Week In PA

USDA NRCS Now Accepting National Conservation Innovation Grant Applications

[Posted: June 7, 2019]


6/10/2019

Go To Preceding Article     Go To Next Article

Return to This PA Environment Digest's Main Page